Common Mistakes When Refinancing for a Lower Rate

A considered look at the errors that can erase the savings from a lower interest rate, and how to avoid each one.

Hero Image for Common Mistakes When Refinancing for a Lower Rate

A lower advertised rate does not always mean a lower cost. Refinancing to a lower interest rate works when the savings outweigh the costs of moving and the new loan suits how you borrow.

At Lexor Finance, we are a Melbourne-based, family-run broking business, and we review refinances for clients across Australia. The same handful of errors appear repeatedly. Each one is avoidable with a little preparation.

Why Do Some Refinances Cost More Than They Save?

A refinance costs more than it saves when the one-off charges are greater than the reduction in interest. The rate is only one part of the calculation.

Moneysmart lists the usual costs of switching: a break fee if you are on a fixed rate, a discharge fee when the old loan closes, and an application fee on the new loan. If you have less than 20 per cent equity, lenders mortgage insurance may also apply. Broker fees, where they are charged, form part of the overall cost as well. These amounts vary between lenders, so we ask for them in writing before recommending a move.

There is some local good news for Victorian borrowers. Mortgage duty was abolished in Victoria from 1 July 2004, so it does not add to the cost of a Victorian refinance.

ASIC's guidance for licensees points the same way. A switch should deliver overall cost savings that outweigh any loss of benefits, or it should clearly suit your requirements and objectives. A refinancing review should compare the total cost of staying with the total cost of moving.

What Happens When You Extend the Loan Term to Lower Repayments?

Extending the term lowers your repayments, but you pay interest for longer, so it is not the same as getting a lower rate. The saving needs to come from the rate itself.

Consider a borrower with $600,000 owing and 25 years remaining. These figures use an illustrative rate of 6.75% p.a. for both loans, so only the term differs. At that rate, principal and interest repayments are roughly $4,145 a month.

The borrower refinances and the new lender resets the term to 30 years. Repayments fall to roughly $3,892 a month, about $254 less. It looks like a win, but the rate has not changed. The only thing that changed is the length of the loan, which means interest is charged for five extra years.

A more useful approach is to ask for the new loan to run over the original 25 years. If the new lender's rate is lower, the repayment falls because of the rate and the original payoff date is kept. ASIC says a consumer should be expressly told when lower repayments come only from a longer term. You can test different terms in our mortgage repayment calculator.

Ready to get started?

Book a chat with a Finance Broker at Lexor Finance today.

Coming Off a Fixed Rate: When Is the Right Time to Refinance?

The right time to refinance a fixed loan is usually when the fixed term ends, because a break fee generally applies if you leave earlier. Break fees apply only to fixed rate loans and are not charged on variable loans.

The fee is a separate charge from a discharge fee, which is payable whether or not you leave early. Exit fees on residential loans signed on or after 1 July 2011 are generally prohibited, but that prohibition does not cover break fees or discharge fees. Ask your lender for a break cost estimate in writing, as the amount depends on your loan and market movements.

Do not wait until the final week. Lenders need time to assess an application and arrange the discharge, so we suggest starting a few months before your fixed rate expiry. Many lenders move borrowers onto a variable rate when a fixed term ends. That rate may not suit you, so check what yours will revert to.

Will You Lose Your Offset Account or Redraw by Refinancing?

You can lose useful features when you move, and you can also gain them. An offset account or redraw facility may be missing from the new loan, or may come at an extra cost.

An offset account reduces the interest charged by counting your savings against the balance. If you hold a large balance in one, a loan with a slightly higher rate and a working offset can cost less than a lower-rate loan without one. The reverse is also true. A feature you never use should not justify paying more.

There is a trade-off the other way. Packaged loans often carry an annual fee, and a variable loan offers flexibility but its rate can rise. Fixing gives certainty on repayments, but limits extra repayments and can trigger a break fee later. We look at how you actually use your loan before comparing products. Our home loan health check is a sensible first step.

Is Refinancing to Release Equity the Same as Refinancing to Lower Your Rate?

No. Refinancing only to secure a lower rate keeps your debt the same, while releasing equity increases it. APRA describes like-for-like refinancing as moving lenders without increasing total debt.

The distinction affects assessment. For a refinance to a lower rate without extra borrowing, ASIC says a lender may give particular weight to your repayment history. It also says that history should cover a sufficiently long period, for example 12 months. If you borrow more, expect a fuller assessment of your income and expenses, and your repayments may rise.

Tax is a further consideration for investors. The ATO states that interest is deductible only on the portion of borrowing used to produce income. If you add funds for a personal purpose when you refinance an investment loan, interest must be apportioned. Because the rules are detailed, speak to your accountant before restructuring an investment loan.

Does Your Lender Know What You Are Paying?

Often the most direct first step is to ask your current lender for a lower rate. Staying put avoids discharge costs, though the lender is under no obligation to match a rival's offer.

Whether you stay or switch, make the comparison on total cost, term and features, not rate alone. That is the comparison we prepare for clients considering a home loan change.

Call one of our team or book an appointment at a time that works for you, and we will work through your numbers with you.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I refinance to a lower rate before my fixed term ends?

Yes, but a break fee generally applies to fixed rate loans that end early. Ask your lender for a written estimate and compare it with the interest you would save.

Does a lower repayment always mean a lower rate?

No. Repayments also fall when the loan term is extended, which means you pay interest for longer. Ask for the new loan to match your remaining term so you can see the effect of the rate alone.

What costs should I check before I refinance?

Check for a break fee, a discharge fee, an application fee and, if your equity is under 20 per cent, lenders mortgage insurance. Broker fees, where charged, count towards the overall cost.

Is refinancing to release equity different from refinancing for a lower rate?

Yes. Releasing equity increases your debt, while a like-for-like refinance does not. If the loan is for an investment property, speak to your accountant about how the interest is treated.


Ready to get started?

Book a chat with a Finance Broker at Lexor Finance today.